Polyurethane Vs. Oil Finish For Hardwood Flooring Gaylord Hardwood Flooring

Heidelberg Wood Floor finishes create lasting beauty and requires minimal care thanks to today’s modern technology in wood floor finish products. On previously waxed or polished surfaces it is essential for an even finish and protection to strip back to bare wood with sandpaper, wire wool and white spirit as necessary. Today it is still known for its capability of flowing out to a smooth and durable finish. Wipe off excess product after 15-30 minutes and after each coat with a lint-free cotton cloth/rag along the grain of the wood.

They offer better protection than oil or oil-varnish blends, but fall short of the supreme toughness of varnishes. If the surface is not clean or has recently been stripped of its finish; it should be cleaned with TSP. Many penetrating oil systems simply require the oil to be applied with either a lambswool brush or roller and buffed into the wood. Ordinary wear is not as noticeable because of the chic Red Oak’s grain and its natural reddish color. I will mention that the oil or solvent based finishes discussed will be oil based polyurethane (sometimes called oil modified poly or OMU).

But on the plus side, oils tend to bring out the character of the wood better, they’re made of natural products, plus they’re very easy to apply and maintain. Only wax a surface finish if the original finish is in poor shape and you don’t plan to refinish your floor in the near future. Let’s start with the basics about the polyurethanes: Oil based poly’s have a typical dry and re-coat time of approximately 24 hours. Should your wood flooring ever need refinishing, please let us know and we would be happy to restore your floors to their original beauty.

In over 100 years of development of synthetic resins and varnishes no one has developed a coating that surpasses the overall performance of natural tung oil. Naturally deciding on the right finish depends on the homeowner’s personal style (low sheen or high sheen?), lifestyle (high traffic family?) and maintenance preference (touch up or complete overhaul?).

While it is true that with a penetrating finish wear does occur directly to the wood, modern oil finishes are much more resistant to wear than those originally used to condition hardwood. Tapes must be removed from the floor on daily basis to avoid damaging the finish. Match with the appropriate finish (gloss or satin) and apply with the micro fiber applicator in broad strokes.

Oil based finishes are a cost-effective option that has been widely used for centuries. Choosing the right finish option is a task that requires a little homework, but is always rewarding. With proper care and adherence to all recommendations regarding floor maintenance, hardwood floors with Hardwax Oil finish will last a lifetime. The natural oils penetrate the grain and become part of the floor, while the surface film of acrylic and polyurethane detracts from the natural beauty of hardwood and degrades with age and use. You could try to lightly wet sand to see if you can remove some of the finish layers until you reach the trapped moisture area.

To get more variation with a medium stain on the floor, we were crazy and actually masked off different individual boards and stained them different variations of the same stain mix of Bona Drifast Jacobean and Natural. Hardwood flooring with Hardwax Oil finish is distinguished by its high repairability. You can also try a diluted mixture or Murphy’s Oil Soap (1/4 cup to 1 gallon of water) or a specific Bona cleaner for your floors.